| 1 | Rev. Noah Jones | November 1827 – January 1834 |
| 2 | Rev. J.C. Meeke | January 1834 – January 1841 |
| 3 | Rev. W.A. Jones | April 1841 – September 1849 |
| 4 | Rev. J.C. Woods | May 1850 – December 1850 |
| 5 | Rev. W.D. Jeremy | April 1851 – December 1852 |
| 6 | Rev. J.S. Gilbert | March 1853 – December 1855 |
| 7 | Rev. Reginald Rogers | 1856-1859 |
| 8 | Rev. J.K. Montgomery | June 1859 – February 1860 |
| 9 | Rev. Percy Bakewell | April 1860 – December 1860 |
| 10 | Rev. Iden Payne | January 1861 – October 1874 |
| 11 | Rev. R.S. Birks | December 1874 – March 1879 |
| 12 | Rev. E.R. Grant | June 1879 – August 1885 |
| 13 | Rev. F. Lawtry | January 1886 – February 1889 |
| 14 | Rev. J.C. Street | January 1890 – February 1891 |
| 15 | Rev. Felix Taylor | March 1891 – February 1894 |
| 16 | Rev. T.W. Freckleton | April 1894 – 1897 |
| 17 | Rev. John Byles | 1898 – 1900 |
| 18 | Rev. A.C. Harvie | 1903 – 1905 |
| 19 | Rev. E.A. Voysey | 1906 – 1910 |
| 20 | Rev. W.C. Hall | 1910 – 1924 |
| 21 | Rev. D.C. Evans | 1924 – 1928 |
| 22 | Rev. H.B. Hannah | 1930 – 1946 |
| 23 | Rev. A.E. Mobbs | 1946 – 1950 |
| 24 | Supply Ministers | 1950 – 1970 |
| 25 | Rev. John Clifford | 1970 – 1973 Avon Group: Banbury, Coventry, Northampton & Warwick. |
| 26 | Rev. Frank Clabburn | 1973-1977 |
| 27 | Supply Ministers | 1977-1981 |
| 28 | Peter Galbraith, Lay Charge | 1981-2000 |
| 29 | Rev. Sue Woolley | 2016- Joint Ministry with Midland Unitarian Association and Banbury |